FastGMs Rating Lists (FGRL)





Comparison - doubling Time control

Conditions:
each 1 Core, 128 MB Hash, ponder off, Book: 8moves_GM.pgn
GUI: Cutechess-Cli

Hardware:
AMD FX-8350 @ 4,6 GHz, Turbo Core off
Fritzmark: 30.41 / 14598

Engines:
Critter 1.6a 64-bit
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64
Houdini 3 x64
Komodo CCT 64-bit
Stockfish 3 Ja 64bit

Evaluation as PDF-File: Comparison - doubling Time control

--------------------------------------------------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------
Time Control: 30.00 sec. + 0.05 sec. per Game                 |  Time Control: 15.00 sec. + 0.05 sec. per Game                 |  Time Control: 7.50 sec. + 0.05 sec. per Game
---------------------------------------------                 |  ---------------------------------------------                 |  --------------------------------------------
                                                              |                                                                |  
ELOStat Start Elo: 3000                                       |                                                                |
                                                              |                                                                |
  Program         Elo   +  -  Games   Score   Av.Op.  Draws   |    Program         Elo   +  -  Games   Score   Av.Op.  Draws   |    Program         Elo   +  -  Games   Score   Av.Op.  Draws
------------------------------------------------------------  |  ------------------------------------------------------------  |  ------------------------------------------------------------
1 Houdini 3     : 3078  3  3  20000   63.7 %   2980   48.5 %  |  1 Houdini 3     : 3083  4  4  20000   64.5 %   2979   46.2 %  |  1 Houdini 3     : 3094  4  4  20000   66.4 %   2976   43.5 %
2 Komodo CCT    : 3012  3  3  20000   52.1 %   2997   48.9 %  |  2 Critter 1.6a  : 3013  3  3  20000   52.4 %   2996   52.1 %  |  2 Critter 1.6a  : 3020  3  3  20000   53.6 %   2995   49.8 %
3 Critter 1.6a  : 3011  3  3  20000   52.0 %   2997   54.2 %  |  3 Komodo CCT    : 3012  3  3  20000   52.2 %   2997   47.4 %  |  3 Komodo CCT    : 3009  4  4  20000   51.6 %   2998   45.6 %
4 Rybka 4.1     : 2953  3  3  20000   41.6 %   3012   47.6 %  |  4 Rybka 4.1     : 2959  4  4  20000   42.8 %   3010   46.5 %  |  4 Rybka 4.1     : 2962  4  4  20000   43.3 %   3009   43.5 %
5 Stockfish 3   : 2946  4  4  20000   40.5 %   3013   46.9 %  |  5 Stockfish 3   : 2932  4  4  20000   38.1 %   3017   44.2 %  |  5 Stockfish 3   : 2914  4  4  20000   35.1 %   3021   40.4 %
                                                              |                                                                |
--------------------------------------------------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------
                                                              |                                                                |
Tournament                                                    |                                                                |
                                                              |                                                                |
  Program         Score      %    Av.Op. Elo   +  -   Draws   |    Program         Score      %    Av.Op. Elo   +  -   Draws   |    Program          Score    %    Av.Op.  Elo   +  -   Draws
------------------------------------------------------------  |  ------------------------------------------------------------  |  ------------------------------------------------------------
1 Houdini 3     : 12741.5  63.7   2980   3078  3  3   48.5 %  |  1 Houdini 3     : 12903.5  64.5   2979   3083  4  4   46.2 %  |  1 Houdini 3     : 13273.0  66.4   2976   3094  4  4   43.5 %
2 Komodo CCT    : 10426.5  52.1   2997   3012  3  3   48.9 %  |  2 Critter 1.6a  : 10479.5  52.4   2996   3013  3  3   52.1 %  |  2 Critter 1.6a  : 10723.5  53.6   2995   3020  3  3   49.8 %
3 Critter 1.6a  : 10402.0  52.0   2997   3011  3  3   54.2 %  |  3 Komodo CCT    : 10445.5  52.2   2997   3012  3  3   47.4 %  |  3 Komodo CCT    : 10322.5  51.6   2998   3009  4  4   45.6 %
4 Rybka 4.1     :  8328.5  41.6   3012   2953  3  3   47.6 %  |  4 Rybka 4.1     :  8552.0  42.8   3010   2959  4  4   46.5 %  |  4 Rybka 4.1     :  8663.0  43.3   3009   2962  4  4   43.5 %
5 Stockfish 3   :  8101.5  40.5   3013   2946  4  4   46.9 %  |  5 Stockfish 3   :  7619.5  38.1   3017   2932  4  4   44.2 %  |  5 Stockfish 3   :  7018.0  35.1   3021   2914  4  4   40.4 %
                                                              |                                                                |
--------------------------------------------------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------
                                                              |                                                                |
Bayeselo                                                      |                                                                |
                                                              |                                                                |
   Program        Elo  +  -  Games  Score  Oppo.  Draws       |    Program        Elo  +  -  Games  Score  Oppo.  Draws        |    Program       Elo  +  -  Games  Score  Oppo. Draws
 -------------------------------------------------------      |  -------------------------------------------------------       |  -----------------------------------------------------
 1 Houdini 3      67   5  4  20000   64 %   -17    48 %       |  1 Houdini 3      72   5  5  20000   65 %   -18    46 %        |  1 Houdini 3      84  5  5  20000   66 %  -21    44 %
 2 Komodo CCT     10   4  4  20000   52 %    -3    49 %       |  2 Critter 1.6a   12   4  4  20000   52 %    -3    52 %        |  2 Critter 1.6a   19  4  4  20000   54 %   -5    50 %
 3 Critter 1.6a   10   4  4  20000   52 %    -2    54 %       |  3 Komodo CCT     11   5  5  20000   52 %    -3    47 %        |  3 Komodo CCT      8  5  5  20000   52 %   -2    46 %
 4 Rybka 4.1     -41   4  4  20000   42 %    10    48 %       |  4 Rybka 4.1     -36   5  4  20000   43 %     9    47 %        |  4 Rybka 4.1     -33  5  5  20000   43 %    8    44 %
 5 Stockfish 3   -47   5  4  20000   41 %    12    47 %       |  5 Stockfish 3   -60   4  4  20000   38 %    15    44 %        |  5 Stockfish 3   -77  5  5  20000   35 %   19    40 %
                                                              |                                                                |
--------------------------------------------------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------
                                                              |                                                                |
   Individual statistics:                                     |                                                                |
                                                              |                                                                |
 1 Houdini 3     : 3078  20000 (+7895,=9693,-2412),  63.7 %   |  1 Houdini 3     : 3083  20000 (+8280,=9247,-2473),  64.5 %    |  1 Houdini 3     : 3094  20000 (+8923,=8700,-2377), 66.4 %
                                                              |                                                                |
   Critter 1.6a  :        5000 (+1484,=2947,-569),   59.2 %   |    Critter 1.6a  :        5000 (+1581,=2794,-625),   59.6 %    |    Critter 1.6a  :        5000 (+1656,=2784,-560),  61.0 %
   Komodo CCT    :        5000 (+1787,=2395,-818),   59.7 %   |    Komodo CCT    :        5000 (+1838,=2361,-801),   60.4 %    |    Komodo CCT    :        5000 (+1965,=2225,-810),  61.6 %
   Rybka 4.1     :        5000 (+2261,=2229,-510),   67.5 %   |    Rybka 4.1     :        5000 (+2280,=2160,-560),   67.2 %    |    Rybka 4.1     :        5000 (+2432,=1976,-592),  68.4 %
   Stockfish 3   :        5000 (+2363,=2122,-515),   68.5 %   |    Stockfish 3   :        5000 (+2581,=1932,-487),   70.9 %    |    Stockfish 3   :        5000 (+2870,=1715,-415),  74.6 %
                                                              |                                                                |
 2 Komodo CCT    : 3012  20000 (+5533,=9787,-4680),  52.1 %   |  2 Critter 1.6a  : 3013  20000 (+5268,=10423,-4309), 52.4 %    |  2 Critter 1.6a  : 3020  20000 (+5741,=9965,-4294), 53.6 %
                                                              |                                                                |
   Houdini 3     :        5000 (+818,=2395,-1787),   40.3 %   |    Houdini 3     :        5000 (+625,=2794,-1581),   40.4 %    |    Houdini 3     :        5000 (+560,=2784,-1656),  39.0 %
   Critter 1.6a  :        5000 (+1172,=2678,-1150),  50.2 %   |    Komodo CCT    :        5000 (+1214,=2577,-1209),  50.0 %    |    Komodo CCT    :        5000 (+1349,=2508,-1143), 52.1 %
   Rybka 4.1     :        5000 (+1780,=2344,-876),   59.0 %   |    Rybka 4.1     :        5000 (+1608,=2602,-790),   58.2 %    |    Rybka 4.1     :        5000 (+1701,=2438,-861),  58.4 %
   Stockfish 3   :        5000 (+1763,=2370,-867),   59.0 %   |    Stockfish 3   :        5000 (+1821,=2450,-729),   60.9 %    |    Stockfish 3   :        5000 (+2131,=2235,-634),  65.0 %
                                                              |                                                                |
 3 Critter 1.6a  : 3011  20000 (+4983,=10838,-4179), 52.0 %   |  3 Komodo CCT    : 3012  20000 (+5704,=9483,-4813),  52.2 %    |  3 Komodo CCT    : 3009  20000 (+5762,=9121,-5117), 51.6 %
                                                              |                                                                |
   Houdini 3     :        5000 (+569,=2947,-1484),   40.8 %   |    Houdini 3     :        5000 (+801,=2361,-1838),   39.6 %    |    Houdini 3     :        5000 (+810,=2225,-1965),  38.5 %
   Komodo CCT    :        5000 (+1150,=2678,-1172),  49.8 %   |    Critter 1.6a  :        5000 (+1209,=2577,-1214),  50.0 %    |    Critter 1.6a  :        5000 (+1143,=2508,-1349), 47.9 %
   Rybka 4.1     :        5000 (+1609,=2636,-755),   58.5 %   |    Rybka 4.1     :        5000 (+1765,=2311,-924),   58.4 %    |    Rybka 4.1     :        5000 (+1705,=2275,-1020), 56.9 %
   Stockfish 3   :        5000 (+1655,=2577,-768),   58.9 %   |    Stockfish 3   :        5000 (+1929,=2234,-837),   60.9 %    |    Stockfish 3   :        5000 (+2104,=2113,-783),  63.2 %
                                                              |                                                                |
 4 Rybka 4.1     : 2953  20000 (+3565,=9527,-6908),  41.6 %   |  4 Rybka 4.1     : 2959  20000 (+3899,=9306,-6795),  42.8 %    |  4 Rybka 4.1     : 2962  20000 (+4312,=8702,-6986), 43.3 %
                                                              |                                                                |
   Houdini 3     :        5000 (+510,=2229,-2261),   32.5 %   |    Houdini 3     :        5000 (+560,=2160,-2280),   32.8 %    |    Houdini 3     :        5000 (+592,=1976,-2432),  31.6 %
   Critter 1.6a  :        5000 (+755,=2636,-1609),   41.5 %   |    Critter 1.6a  :        5000 (+790,=2602,-1608),   41.8 %    |    Critter 1.6a  :        5000 (+861,=2438,-1701),  41.6 %
   Komodo CCT    :        5000 (+876,=2344,-1780),   41.0 %   |    Komodo CCT    :        5000 (+924,=2311,-1765),   41.6 %    |    Komodo CCT    :        5000 (+1020,=2275,-1705), 43.1 %
   Stockfish 3   :        5000 (+1424,=2318,-1258),  51.7 %   |    Stockfish 3   :        5000 (+1625,=2233,-1142),  54.8 %    |    Stockfish 3   :        5000 (+1839,=2013,-1148), 56.9 %
                                                              |                                                                |
 5 Stockfish 3   : 2946  20000 (+3408,=9387,-7205),  40.5 %   |  5 Stockfish 3   : 2932  20000 (+3195,=8849,-7956),  38.1 %    |  5 Stockfish 3   : 2914  20000 (+2980,=8076,-8944), 35.1 %
                                                              |                                                                |
   Houdini 3     :        5000 (+515,=2122,-2363),   31.5 %   |    Houdini 3     :        5000 (+487,=1932,-2581),   29.1 %    |    Houdini 3     :        5000 (+415,=1715,-2870),  25.4 %
   Critter 1.6a  :        5000 (+768,=2577,-1655),   41.1 %   |    Critter 1.6a  :        5000 (+729,=2450,-1821),   39.1 %    |    Critter 1.6a  :        5000 (+634,=2235,-2131),  35.0 %
   Komodo CCT    :        5000 (+867,=2370,-1763),   41.0 %   |    Komodo CCT    :        5000 (+837,=2234,-1929),   39.1 %    |    Komodo CCT    :        5000 (+783,=2113,-2104),  36.8 %
   Rybka 4.1     :        5000 (+1258,=2318,-1424),  48.3 %   |    Rybka 4.1     :        5000 (+1142,=2233,-1625),  45.2 %    |    Rybka 4.1     :        5000 (+1148,=2013,-1839), 43.1 %
                                                              |                                                                |
--------------------------------------------------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------
                                                              |                                                                |
   Games        :  50000 (finished)                           |    Games        :  50000 (finished)                            |    Games        :  50000 (finished)
                                                              |                                                                |
   White Wins   :  15329 (30.7 %)                             |    White Wins   :  15723 (31.4 %)                              |    White Wins   :  16164 (32.3 %)
   Black Wins   :  10055 (20.1 %)                             |    Black Wins   :  10623 (21.2 %)                              |    Black Wins   :  11554 (23.1 %)
   Draws        :  24616 (49.2 %)                             |    Draws        :  23654 (47.3 %)                              |    Draws        :  22282 (44.6 %)
                                                              |                                                                |
   White Perf.  : 55.3 %                                      |    White Perf.  : 55.1 %                                       |    White Perf.  : 54.6 %
   Black Perf.  : 44.7 %                                      |    Black Perf.  : 44.9 %                                       |    Black Perf.  : 45.4 %
                                                              |                                                                |
   ECO A =  20213 Games (40.4 %)                              |    ECO A =  20181 Games (40.4 %)                               |    ECO A =  20138 Games (40.3 %)
   ECO B =  11993 Games (24.0 %)                              |    ECO B =  12140 Games (24.3 %)                               |    ECO B =  12026 Games (24.1 %)
   ECO C =   6635 Games (13.3 %)                              |    ECO C =   6499 Games (13.0 %)                               |    ECO C =   6636 Games (13.3 %)
   ECO D =   5193 Games (10.4 %)                              |    ECO D =   5320 Games (10.6 %)                               |    ECO D =   5208 Games (10.4 %)
   ECO E =   5966 Games (11.9 %)                              |    ECO E =   5860 Games (11.7 %)                               |    ECO E =   5992 Games (12.0 %)
                                                              |                                                                |
--------------------------------------------------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------