FastGMs Rating Lists
(FGRL)
Comparison - doubling Time control
Conditions:
each 1 Core, 128 MB Hash,
ponder off, Book: 8moves_GM.pgn
GUI: Cutechess-Cli
Hardware:
AMD FX-8350 @ 4,6 GHz, Turbo
Core off
Fritzmark: 30.41 / 14598
Engines:
Critter 1.6a 64-bit
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64
Houdini 3 x64
Komodo CCT 64-bit
Stockfish 3 Ja 64bit
Evaluation as PDF-File: Comparison -
doubling Time control
--------------------------------------------------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------
Time Control: 30.00 sec. + 0.05 sec. per
Game
| Time Control: 15.00 sec. +
0.05 sec. per
Game
| Time Control: 7.50 sec. +
0.05 sec. per Game
---------------------------------------------
|
---------------------------------------------
| --------------------------------------------
|
|
ELOStat Start Elo:
3000
|
|
|
|
Program Elo
+ - Games Score Av.Op.
Draws |
Program Elo
+ - Games Score Av.Op.
Draws |
Program Elo
+ - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
------------------------------------------------------------
|
------------------------------------------------------------
| ------------------------------------------------------------
1 Houdini
3 : 3078 3 3
20000 63.7 % 2980 48.5 %
| 1 Houdini 3 : 3083 4
4 20000 64.5 % 2979 46.2
% | 1 Houdini 3 : 3094
4 4 20000 66.4 % 2976
43.5 %
2 Komodo CCT
: 3012 3 3 20000 52.1 %
2997 48.9 % | 2 Critter 1.6a : 3013
3 3 20000 52.4 % 2996
52.1 % | 2 Critter 1.6a : 3020 3 3
20000 53.6 % 2995 49.8 %
3 Critter 1.6a :
3011 3 3 20000 52.0 %
2997 54.2 % | 3 Komodo CCT :
3012 3 3 20000 52.2 %
2997 47.4 % | 3 Komodo CCT :
3009 4 4 20000 51.6 %
2998 45.6 %
4 Rybka
4.1 : 2953 3 3
20000 41.6 % 3012 47.6 %
| 4 Rybka 4.1 : 2959 4
4 20000 42.8 % 3010 46.5
% | 4 Rybka 4.1 : 2962
4 4 20000 43.3 % 3009
43.5 %
5 Stockfish 3 :
2946 4 4 20000 40.5 %
3013 46.9 % | 5 Stockfish 3 :
2932 4 4 20000 38.1 %
3017 44.2 % | 5 Stockfish 3 :
2914 4 4 20000 35.1 %
3021 40.4 %
|
|
--------------------------------------------------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
Tournament
|
|
|
|
Program
Score % Av.Op.
Elo + - Draws
|
Program
Score % Av.Op.
Elo + - Draws
|
Program
Score % Av.Op.
Elo + - Draws
------------------------------------------------------------
|
------------------------------------------------------------
| ------------------------------------------------------------
1 Houdini
3 : 12741.5 63.7
2980 3078 3 3 48.5 % |
1 Houdini 3 : 12903.5 64.5
2979 3083 4 4 46.2 % |
1 Houdini 3 : 13273.0 66.4
2976 3094 4 4 43.5 %
2 Komodo CCT
: 10426.5 52.1 2997 3012 3
3 48.9 % | 2 Critter 1.6a : 10479.5
52.4 2996 3013 3 3 52.1
% | 2 Critter 1.6a : 10723.5 53.6
2995 3020 3 3 49.8 %
3 Critter 1.6a :
10402.0 52.0 2997 3011 3
3 54.2 % | 3 Komodo CCT :
10445.5 52.2 2997 3012 3
3 47.4 % | 3 Komodo CCT :
10322.5 51.6 2998 3009 4
4 45.6 %
4 Rybka
4.1 : 8328.5 41.6
3012 2953 3 3 47.6 % |
4 Rybka 4.1 : 8552.0
42.8 3010 2959 4 4 46.5
% | 4 Rybka 4.1 :
8663.0 43.3 3009 2962 4
4 43.5 %
5 Stockfish 3
: 8101.5 40.5 3013 2946
4 4 46.9 % | 5 Stockfish 3
: 7619.5 38.1 3017 2932
4 4 44.2 % | 5 Stockfish 3
: 7018.0 35.1 3021 2914
4 4 40.4 %
|
|
--------------------------------------------------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
Bayeselo
|
|
|
|
Program Elo +
- Games Score Oppo.
Draws |
Program Elo +
- Games Score Oppo.
Draws |
Program Elo + -
Games Score Oppo. Draws
-------------------------------------------------------
|
-------------------------------------------------------
| -----------------------------------------------------
1 Houdini
3 67 5 4
20000 64 % -17 48
% | 1 Houdini
3 72 5 5
20000 65 % -18 46
% | 1 Houdini
3 84 5 5
20000 66 % -21 44 %
2 Komodo
CCT 10 4 4
20000 52 % -3 49
% | 2 Critter
1.6a 12 4 4 20000 52
% -3 52
% | 2 Critter
1.6a 19 4 4 20000 54
% -5 50 %
3 Critter
1.6a 10 4 4 20000 52
% -2 54
% | 3 Komodo
CCT 11 5 5
20000 52 % -3 47
% | 3 Komodo
CCT 8 5 5
20000 52 % -2 46 %
4 Rybka
4.1 -41 4 4
20000 42 % 10 48
% | 4 Rybka
4.1 -36 5 4
20000 43 % 9 47
% | 4 Rybka
4.1 -33 5 5 20000
43 % 8 44 %
5 Stockfish 3
-47 5 4 20000 41
% 12 47
% | 5 Stockfish 3
-60 4 4 20000 38
% 15 44
% | 5 Stockfish
3 -77 5 5 20000 35
% 19 40 %
|
|
--------------------------------------------------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
Individual
statistics:
|
|
|
|
1 Houdini
3 : 3078 20000 (+7895,=9693,-2412),
63.7 % | 1 Houdini 3 :
3083 20000 (+8280,=9247,-2473), 64.5 %
| 1 Houdini 3 : 3094 20000
(+8923,=8700,-2377), 66.4 %
|
|
Critter 1.6a
: 5000
(+1484,=2947,-569), 59.2 % |
Critter 1.6a : 5000
(+1581,=2794,-625), 59.6 %
| Critter 1.6a
: 5000
(+1656,=2784,-560), 61.0 %
Komodo
CCT : 5000
(+1787,=2395,-818), 59.7 % |
Komodo CCT
: 5000
(+1838,=2361,-801), 60.4 %
| Komodo CCT
: 5000
(+1965,=2225,-810), 61.6 %
Rybka
4.1 :
5000 (+2261,=2229,-510), 67.5 %
| Rybka 4.1
: 5000
(+2280,=2160,-560), 67.2 %
| Rybka 4.1
: 5000
(+2432,=1976,-592), 68.4 %
Stockfish
3 : 5000
(+2363,=2122,-515), 68.5 % |
Stockfish 3 :
5000 (+2581,=1932,-487), 70.9 %
| Stockfish 3
: 5000
(+2870,=1715,-415), 74.6 %
|
|
2 Komodo
CCT : 3012 20000 (+5533,=9787,-4680),
52.1 % | 2 Critter 1.6a : 3013 20000
(+5268,=10423,-4309), 52.4 % | 2 Critter
1.6a : 3020 20000 (+5741,=9965,-4294), 53.6 %
|
|
Houdini
3 :
5000 (+818,=2395,-1787), 40.3 %
| Houdini 3
: 5000
(+625,=2794,-1581), 40.4 %
| Houdini 3
: 5000
(+560,=2784,-1656), 39.0 %
Critter 1.6a
: 5000
(+1172,=2678,-1150), 50.2 % |
Komodo CCT
: 5000
(+1214,=2577,-1209), 50.0 % |
Komodo CCT
: 5000 (+1349,=2508,-1143),
52.1 %
Rybka
4.1 :
5000 (+1780,=2344,-876), 59.0 %
| Rybka 4.1
: 5000
(+1608,=2602,-790), 58.2 %
| Rybka 4.1
: 5000
(+1701,=2438,-861), 58.4 %
Stockfish
3 : 5000
(+1763,=2370,-867), 59.0 % |
Stockfish 3 :
5000 (+1821,=2450,-729), 60.9 %
| Stockfish 3
: 5000
(+2131,=2235,-634), 65.0 %
|
|
3 Critter 1.6a :
3011 20000 (+4983,=10838,-4179), 52.0 % | 3
Komodo CCT : 3012 20000
(+5704,=9483,-4813), 52.2 % | 3 Komodo
CCT : 3009 20000 (+5762,=9121,-5117), 51.6 %
|
|
Houdini
3 :
5000 (+569,=2947,-1484), 40.8 %
| Houdini 3
: 5000
(+801,=2361,-1838), 39.6 %
| Houdini 3
: 5000
(+810,=2225,-1965), 38.5 %
Komodo
CCT : 5000
(+1150,=2678,-1172), 49.8 % |
Critter 1.6a : 5000
(+1209,=2577,-1214), 50.0 % |
Critter 1.6a : 5000
(+1143,=2508,-1349), 47.9 %
Rybka
4.1 :
5000 (+1609,=2636,-755), 58.5 %
| Rybka 4.1
: 5000
(+1765,=2311,-924), 58.4 %
| Rybka 4.1
: 5000 (+1705,=2275,-1020),
56.9 %
Stockfish
3 : 5000
(+1655,=2577,-768), 58.9 % |
Stockfish 3 :
5000 (+1929,=2234,-837), 60.9 %
| Stockfish 3
: 5000
(+2104,=2113,-783), 63.2 %
|
|
4 Rybka
4.1 : 2953 20000
(+3565,=9527,-6908), 41.6 % | 4 Rybka
4.1 : 2959 20000
(+3899,=9306,-6795), 42.8 % | 4 Rybka
4.1 : 2962 20000 (+4312,=8702,-6986),
43.3 %
|
|
Houdini
3 :
5000 (+510,=2229,-2261), 32.5 %
| Houdini 3
: 5000
(+560,=2160,-2280), 32.8 %
| Houdini 3
: 5000
(+592,=1976,-2432), 31.6 %
Critter 1.6a
: 5000
(+755,=2636,-1609), 41.5 % |
Critter 1.6a : 5000
(+790,=2602,-1608), 41.8 %
| Critter 1.6a
: 5000
(+861,=2438,-1701), 41.6 %
Komodo
CCT : 5000
(+876,=2344,-1780), 41.0 % |
Komodo CCT
: 5000
(+924,=2311,-1765), 41.6 %
| Komodo CCT
: 5000 (+1020,=2275,-1705),
43.1 %
Stockfish
3 : 5000
(+1424,=2318,-1258), 51.7 % |
Stockfish 3 :
5000 (+1625,=2233,-1142), 54.8 %
| Stockfish 3
: 5000 (+1839,=2013,-1148),
56.9 %
|
|
5 Stockfish 3
: 2946 20000 (+3408,=9387,-7205), 40.5 %
| 5 Stockfish 3 : 2932 20000
(+3195,=8849,-7956), 38.1 % | 5 Stockfish
3 : 2914 20000 (+2980,=8076,-8944), 35.1 %
|
|
Houdini
3 :
5000 (+515,=2122,-2363), 31.5 %
| Houdini 3
: 5000
(+487,=1932,-2581), 29.1 %
| Houdini 3
: 5000
(+415,=1715,-2870), 25.4 %
Critter 1.6a
: 5000
(+768,=2577,-1655), 41.1 % |
Critter 1.6a : 5000
(+729,=2450,-1821), 39.1 %
| Critter 1.6a
: 5000
(+634,=2235,-2131), 35.0 %
Komodo
CCT : 5000
(+867,=2370,-1763), 41.0 % |
Komodo CCT
: 5000
(+837,=2234,-1929), 39.1 %
| Komodo CCT
: 5000
(+783,=2113,-2104), 36.8 %
Rybka
4.1 :
5000 (+1258,=2318,-1424), 48.3 % |
Rybka 4.1
: 5000
(+1142,=2233,-1625), 45.2 % |
Rybka 4.1
: 5000 (+1148,=2013,-1839),
43.1 %
|
|
--------------------------------------------------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------
|
|
Games : 50000
(finished)
| Games
: 50000
(finished)
| Games
: 50000 (finished)
|
|
White
Wins : 15329 (30.7
%)
| White Wins : 15723 (31.4
%)
| White Wins : 16164 (32.3 %)
Black
Wins : 10055 (20.1
%)
| Black Wins : 10623 (21.2
%)
| Black Wins : 11554 (23.1 %)
Draws : 24616 (49.2
%)
| Draws
: 23654 (47.3
%)
| Draws
: 22282 (44.6 %)
|
|
White Perf.
: 55.3
%
| White Perf. : 55.1
%
| White Perf. : 54.6 %
Black Perf.
: 44.7
%
| Black Perf. : 44.9
%
| Black Perf. : 45.4 %
|
|
ECO A =
20213 Games (40.4
%)
| ECO A = 20181 Games (40.4
%)
| ECO A = 20138 Games (40.3 %)
ECO B =
11993 Games (24.0
%)
| ECO B = 12140 Games (24.3
%)
| ECO B = 12026 Games (24.1 %)
ECO C
= 6635 Games (13.3
%)
| ECO C = 6499 Games (13.0
%)
| ECO C = 6636 Games (13.3 %)
ECO D
= 5193 Games (10.4
%)
| ECO D = 5320 Games (10.6
%)
| ECO D = 5208 Games (10.4 %)
ECO E
= 5966 Games (11.9
%)
| ECO E = 5860 Games (11.7
%)
| ECO E = 5992 Games (12.0 %)
|
|
--------------------------------------------------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------